Classic Corner: The Haunting Of Hill House

Rating:
Rated 3 out of 5

Title: The Haunting Of Hill House

Author: Shirley Jackson

Year: 1959

Genre: Horror, Psychological Fiction

Note: This review does contain spoilers.

In this post, I review Shirley Jackson’s modern classic horror story, the Haunting of Hill House, which was made into a Netflix series. The book was chosen as this months read for my local book shop’s book club and though it is my first time reading this book, I have reviewed Shirley Jackson’s We Have Always Lived In The Castle so I was keen to give this one a try.

Plot

Alone in the world following the death of her mother, Eleanor is excited to take up an offer from a mysterious Dr. Montague to spend a summer in the mysterious Hill House, a house which has a busy history and is believed to be haunted. Dr. Montague wants to investigate the paranormal sightings so that he can write a book on the subject.

Joining Eleanor and Dr. Montague is Theodora, a city-girl and “sensitive” type and Luke, the heir to Hill House. Initially the investigation begins in a light-hearted way but as strange and terrifying events begin the happen, the experiment proves to be a trip into their darkest nightmares, an experiment that not all of them might survive…

Thoughts

Overall I found this book very difficult to rate and to decide whether I liked it or not and had a very similar reaction to it as I did to We Have Always Lived In The Castle.

When I finished reading it I wasn’t entirely sure whether I had enjoyed what I read, whilst I feel Jackson did a good job of creating an eerie and creepy atmosphere in the book, I did find that I was expecting some kind of resolution to what happens and the mystery when it doesn’t really provide that, with Eleanor crashing her car in a somewhat abrupt ending.

I felt from the characters point of view that whilst Eleanor who is probably the main protagonist is quite well developed, many of the other characters are quite one-dimensional, Theodora being the city-girl type, Luke being the heir and Dr. Montague being a scientist and that is all that we really get from them. Similarly, whilst Hill House was definitely imposing and creepy at the opening of the story I found the setting very hard to imagine as it was being described and as a result I felt I didn’t really get into it.

I also had a conversation with my friend Jane over at Witches Brewbooks who had read this story before and she really disliked the novel too from her review.

However, when we had our book club discussion on it I found that other people in the group had some different perspectives on it and in a similar way to We Have Always Lived In The Castle, it was more about what was how the reader interprets it that makes it much more interesting as it seemed like everybody had their own viewpoint.

A couple of the theories that resonated with me were:

The book is entirely in Eleanor’s head, the characters and the setting of Hill House are all part of the fantasies that she had and they are manifesting in her head. Some of the evidence was that things mentioned on Eleanor’s journey to Hill House seemed to crop up within conversation or in the house, also the characters being quite one-dimensional on the page because they are just caricatures of her imagination. Also Hill House may be hard to imagine because it is a manifestation of someone’s mind that isn’t quite built right.

Another was the experiment was actually being done on Eleanor herself, kind of in a similar situation to what happens to Leonardo Dicaprio’s character in Shutter Island and letting the situation play out so that the other characters can see what is wrong with her.

A third one is that Eleanor was a ghost or the spirit of Nell who was one of the past residents of Hill House.

Personally of these the one that it is Eleanor’s fantasy resonated with me the most but from the discussion it did make me re-evaluate what I had read and realised it was a deeper and more interesting read than I had first thought, however I can admit at face value the book may not be very entertaining, particularly if you have come from the Netflix show, as the book is a very different experience that for people who have watched the show first may not be as good as reading the book first.

If you have read this book, or seen the Netflix show, let me know in the comments down below what your thoughts were.

Share this!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *