As part of my recent series of posts celebrating the 100th anniversary of the publication of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby, I have taken a look at the high profile screen adaptations of the novel that have been released over the years, in 1949, 1974, 2000 and 2013 respectively.
However there is one more adaptation that was released less than 18 months after the novel’s publication in 1926. Sadly this movie is now considered lost but the story of the movie was fascinating enough to pique my interest.
This 1926 silent movie was directed by Herbert Brenon and starred Warren Baxter as Gatsby, Lois Wilson as Daisy and Neil Hamilton as Nick Carraway. It was based on the Broadway adaptation that had premiered earlier that year in February (itself being staged less than a year after the novel was published). It was also the only adaptation to be made of Gatsby in Fitzgerald’s lifetime, as he passed away from heart failure in 1940 so didn’t get to see the revival of his work post World War Two, or the 1949 adaptation.
What do we know about the adaptation?
As mentioned above the original print of the film is considered lost, although we do have a 1 minute trailer that was used to promote the movie and from various contemporary reviews we can glean some information from what happens in this adaptation.
This is the trailer for the movie:
This next part is pure speculation as the full movie is now lost and the footage is very brief but these are my thoughts on what I believe the trailer shows:
After an opening title card and a strapline highlighting the book and the play’s success and how it is now a movie we see a couple of shots from the movie itself.
The first proper scene looks to show Gatsby and Daisy meeting in Chapter Five. They both turn to look at each other and there is a close up shot of Lois Wilson’s Daisy staring into the camera and breathing heavily from the shock.
The second scene then cuts possibly to the end when Nick discovers Gatsby’s dead body and is holding the revolver possibly used by George to kill him.
The third scene shows Daisy and Gatsby in an embrace, this is probably also from the second half of the novel although it is not clear where it’s from. However Gatsby’s jacket does seem military-esque so I think this could possibly be when Jordan recounts Daisy’s initial relationship with Gatsby when she was Daisy Fay.
The trailer then says “No need to talk about these pictures, here are some sample scenes” with shots of Gatsby’s wild parties. Slightly bizarrely the party scenes all seem to have women in swimming costumes diving into pools and running around Gatsby’s mansion, where we see the swimming pool with a staircase behind it, and possibly a front room with a spiral staircase. Whilst Gatsby does obviously have a pool in the novel I don’t remember from any descriptions of the parties in the novel lots of people wearing swimming costumes or being pool parties.
The final shot from the movie looks to be from the confrontation at the Plaza Hotel where we see Jordan, Tom, Nick, Daisy and Gatsby and Daisy suddenly stands out of her chair.
The trailer then alludes to the T.J. Eckleburg sign with the final strapline to “Come and see it all and enjoy the entertainment thrill of your life! The Great Gatsby is ‘Great!’”.
Of course from the trailer there is very little that we can see about the actors and how well they portray the characters. The only immediate thoughts I did have is Warren Baxter in the possible flashback scene with Daisy does look a tad too old to play Gatsby, similarly to how Leonardo Dicaprio looked in the 2013 version. However Lois Wilson’s eyes look extremely dramatic and wide-eyed in the scene where she reunites with him, almost like she is appearing in a horror film.
Stills
The movie also has a series of stills that are available to view on IMDB, many of them are shots from the trailer, although there are additional stills of what appears to be other locations such as Nick Carraway’s condo, which looks a little too big to be accurate, as well as George’s garage in the Valley of Ashes from the outside. Also fascinating amongst the images is a letter from Virginia’s censor board telling Paramount to cut out several “suggestive” scenes such as “close ups of girls legs…eliminate close up view of men and women in bathing suits in suggestive postures on raft”. This also suggests like the 1949 movie, the film had to heavily adapt the story due to themes that were seen as indecent to be shown on screen.
Changes to the novel
According to the movie’s Wikipedia page, the film did deviate from the plot in a few ways. Daisy renounces Gatsby in the Plaza Hotel when Tom accuses him of being a bootlegger, not when Gatsby tries to make Daisy say she never loved Tom like he does in the book. Also in this version, Daisy tries to confess to the hit and run but somehow fails to do so, how she does this though isn’t quite clear.
Finally in this version Daisy and Tom leave New York before George kills Gatsby, making them seemingly unaware of his death, although the final shot of the movie was said to show them with their daughter Pammy seated on the porch of their home, showing them retreating to a life of carelessness.
Similarly in critical reception of the movie, Mordaunt Hall of the New York Times wrote that Daisy gulps absinthe and “takes enough of this beverage to render the average person unconscious. Yet she appears only mildly intoxicated, and soon recovers”. This perhaps misses the point when one of Fitzgerald’s themes in the novel is how the excesses of the Jazz Age will catch up with people. However it is interesting this was cleared by the censors in 1926, when the film was released in the midst of prohibition, but other scenes that depicted adultery or sex outside marriage were considered amoral and needed to be cut.
Furthermore, Abel Green’s review in Variety at the time comments on Daisy’s rejection of Gatsby due to him being a bootlegger, stating that it is not “”a heinous crime despite the existence of a federal statute which declares it so.””, which perhaps serves to highlight that despite prohibition, drinking wasn’t seen as that amoral which is a fascinating contradiction to what we know at the time.
Another scene described in Hall’s review is when Gatsby throws gold coins into his pool, causing the partygoers to dive in after them, although he comments in his review “Gatsby appears to throw the money into the water with a good deal of interest, whereas it might perhaps have been more effective to have him appear a little bored as he watched the scramble of the men and women.” Of course nothing like this happens in the novel, although I wonder if it was intended as a visual metaphor that all the partygoers are there just to take advantage of Gatsby’s wealth and hospitality, not because of any great love for him, although Gatsby really should be more distant in this scene than how it is described in the review even if this was the intention.
Fitzgerald’s reaction
This is the only adaptation to be released in Fitzgerald’s lifetime although according to Wikipedia it is not entirely clear what Fitzgerald’s reaction was.
This is perhaps because it is vastly overshadowed by his wife’s, Zelda Sayre’s reaction. She and Fitzgerald went to see the movie at a local theatre in 1927 and she wrote a letter afterwards to her daughter Scottie and her nanny, describing it as “rotten and awful and terrible and we left” presumably before it was finished.
However, this is not the recollection of other people associated with the movie, with Lois Wilson who portrayed Daisy stating that she had met Fitzgerald in Hollywood and he seemed to like the film. Also in Fitzgerald’s personal scrapbook he had pasted in a positive review of the movie.
What is the status of the original movie now?
In 1948, RKO Pictures Screenwriter DeWitt Bodeen requested to see the badly damaged master copy of the film in order to research it for the 1949 version that was at the time entering pre-production, although apparently at that time the print kept jamming, showing the movie’s poor condition even then.
According to Wikipedia, in 2003, Wheeler Winston Dixon, the James Ryan Professor of Film Studies at the University of Nebraska–Lincoln, made extensive but unsuccessful attempts to find a surviving print of the 1926 version. Dixon noted that there were rumours that a copy survived in an unknown archive in Moscow but dismissed these rumors as unfounded”. Of course with the current situation in Russia and Ukraine it is unlikely this copy will be found anytime soon if it is real. At the time of writing all that survives is the trailer and stills.
In conclusion, whilst I have never watched a silent movie, it would be fascinating to see this movie, being the only adaptation that Fitzgerald saw of his greatest work in his lifetime so I hope in the future this movie is found in its complete form somewhere.
This post concludes my overview of all of the film adaptations and we are now moving on to a different medium entirely, audio dramas and starting with a very recent release, a 2025 BBC adaptation called Gatsby in Harlem which relocates the story to Harlem with an all-black voice cast including Ncuti Gatwa as Gatsby.
