Age Rating (UK/US): 12A / PG-13
Update – 04/01/2026: Continuing on with my recent blog series taking a deep dive into F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby, I’ve been watching all of the screen adaptations of the novel. I’ve now arrived at the most recent adaptation, released in 2013 and directed by Baz Lurhmann. I had reviewed this movie on the blog before back in 2022, when I also reviewed the novel on here, so I have updated this older post with my recent thoughts from my latest rewatch.
I will also add at the time of updating this post I have watched the movie adaptations slightly out of sequence, I had intended to watch them in release order, starting with the 1949 adaptation, however this one was only on Amazon Prime for a few more days so I decided to watch this one prior to the 1974 movie and the 2000 TV movie.
Anyway here is the trailer for the movie:
The visuals of Gatsby
First of all the movie is very visually striking and the visual presentation really brings to the screen the opulence, decadence and wild debauchery of Fitzgerald’s novel. Baz Luhrmann as a filmmaker is known for his stylistic visuals and if you have seen his other movies such as Romeo + Juliet and especially Moulin Rouge he does a great job of bringing this visual presentation to Fitzgerald’s descriptions of 1920s New York. In particular Gatsby’s parties feel like wild and crazed affairs and even the much smaller party Tom and Myrtle have in their apartment feels like a wild drink and drug-induced frenzy that fits the wildness of the period. This definitely contrasts with the 1949 movie where the parties were shown as quite prim and proper and lost some of that wild edge. The way Luhrmann visualises these parties has clearly shaped how modern audiences imagine the Jazz Age, and it’s easy to see why Gatsby-inspired parties and events have become so popular in the years since.
However I did notice in this rewatch some very iffy looking photoshop where Leonardo Dicaprio’s Gatsby is photoshopped into the pictures. Whilst it perhaps is funny and symbolizes the illusion vs reality theme of the novel, it also comes across as bad special effects and takes you out of the realism of the 1920s, especially as nothing within the original novel implied the photos were faked, just that Gatsby grossly exaggerated the stories around them.
Changes to the novel
This also brings me on nicely to changes to the original text, overall the movie is pretty accurate to the novel’s events, especially in comparison to the 1949 movie which deviated quite a lot from the original novel.
The only real major change that I spotted was the opening scene. In this depiction Nick is seeing a therapist following what happened in the novel’s events. His medical card shows he is suffering from alcohol addiction, anxiety, depression and insomnia. His initial conversation with the therapist introduces the story of Gatsby and the therapist suggests he writes down what happens.
In my previous watch I remember this wasn’t something I was a massive fan of although I have changed my mind a little. My thoughts at the time was this was done as an attempt to present Nick as an unreliable narrator of the movie, like he is in the book but it gives the impression he was mentally ill, not unreliable. However on re-evaluating it I think this is a way of showing that the events of the movie have affected Nick, which does draw in viewers unfamiliar with the novel who will want to know what has affected him. It also presents Nick the writer to the viewer and connects him back to the original novel. It also does make more sense the events have affected him in this way, whereas in the older movie he moved on, married Jordan and is pretty scornful of Gatsby’s actions.
I also realised it raised another question of the original text. Nick condemns Tom and Daisy and disapproves that they let Gatsby take the fall for the hit and run, but he doesn’t actually do anything about it in the novel i.e. he could have gone to the police but chooses not to. This does show in the novel perhaps Nick’s own moral decay but in the movie it is addressed that Nick does this out of some kind of loyalty to Daisy, perhaps as she is his cousin.
Probably the only other major change is that many moments with Jordan and Nick are cut from the movie, especially after Daisy and Jay start their affair and the movie switches to them which does dampen their relationship somewhat.
There are also a few minor tweaks to the novel. I did mention in my previous review that the car crash outside Gatsby’s party isn’t included but I did realise as Nick is leaving a car is overturned so it is implied but not explicitly mentioned. Also when Gatsby dies the movie has only Nick attend the funeral, not Gatsby’s father and Owl Eyes. Also Nick’s final meeting with Tom and also the scene outside Gatsby’s where Tom invites Gatsby to dinner out of politeness and makes a quick getaway are omitted.
Casting
In my original review, I mentioned that I didn’t really believe Leonardo Dicaprio as Gatsby and neither did I believe in Tobey Maguire as Nick who didn’t engage me at all compared to the character in the book and I have to admit this still stood on my rewatch. I also noticed both actors look much older than the characters they play. Gatsby actually says in the movie he is 32 and Nick turns 30 during the novel as we know but both Dicaprio and Maguire were 39 and 38 when the movie was made and it unfortunately shows. I do think both actors could have played the parts at an earlier stage of their career.
Similar to the 1949 version, I felt Joel Edgerton’s portrayal of Tom Buchanan to be smarmy but not have the brutish quality that he has in the novel, a feeling that he could let rip at any moment.
I do agree with my original review that I felt Carey Mulligan was great at capturing Daisy, especially the sense she is wide-eyed and innocent in the opening chapter, but actually knows exactly what is going on and is choosing to ignore it for appearances sake. However I did feel her chemistry with Dicaprio which much of the movie hinges on is lacking.
I also enjoyed Elizabeth Debicki’s portrayal of Jordan as she had a slightly aloof and even icy tone to the performance that I felt was much closer to the original character in the novel than Ruth Hussey’s version in 1949. This also makes it a shame that scenes she has with Nick are cut as I would have liked to see her in the movie more.
Score
In my original review, I noted that the strangest part of the film is the score – though I do remember the films release and some of the songs which came from the soundtrack were quite popular hits, such as Will.I.Am’s Bang Bang and Emeli Sande’s jazz cover of Beyonce’s Crazy In Love (videos below).
Though I did like these songs separately to the film, in my previous watch I found the soundtrack to be really jarring and immersion breaking as it also features rap music. This second rewatch, perhaps as I was expecting it I didn’t mind it as much and perhaps using a genre of music which is known for being rebellious and against the system today, alongside big band and jazz 1920’s music which was the rap music of the 1920s in some respect is perhaps a more interesting choice than I first thought.
However one thing I can agree on with my original review is the movie does still feel quite slow in places and though I did enjoy this watch more than the first one, I can imagine the average viewer getting quite bored and I did recall on my previous watch I started to feel like it was sending me to sleep.
Conclusion
In my first review of this movie, I gave it 2 stars, after this rewatch, I have decided to increase it to 3. After seeing the 1949 version, I liked Baz Luhrmann’s visual pomp and the score a bit more which I felt reflected the decadence of the novel more closely. However I still think the casting isn’t quite right and the movie is slow in places which may stop it from being a classic movie for most viewers.
Up next, I go a step back in time to the 1974 adaptation, which you can read my review of here.
