Few novels have inspired as many adaptations as F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby. As part of my series celebrating the 100th anniversary of the novel’s publication, I have indeed reviewed quite a number of them here, as well as various print editions of The Great Gatsby that readers may want to add to their collection.
As well as physical editions, the novel has had a number of recent audiobook adaptations, from celebrity narrations to more faithful literary readings. However choosing the best version as an audiobook listener can be difficult.
In this guide I have taken a look at audiobook adaptations of the novel listed on Audible, compared ratings and reviews to give you the best options for listening to this American classic.
NB: This post does contain affiliate links and whilst I haven’t tested every product, I have read the reviews to see if the product is worth recommending. Ratings and review counts are based on Audible UK listings at the time of writing and may change over time.
The Great Gatsby audiobooks compared:
Quick answer:
🥇 Best overall: Jake Gyllenhaal (Audible Studios)
🎓 Best for literary fans: William Hope (Naxos)
🎭 Best immersive experience: BBC Radio Collection
📖 Most traditional: Bolinda Publishing
| Published | Narrator | Rating | Style | Best For |
| Audible Studios | Jake Gyllenhaal | 4.4★ | Cinematic | Modern Listeners |
| Bolinda | Humphrey Bower | 4.4★ | Traditional | Traditional Narration |
| Naxos | William Hope | 4.3★ | Literary | Classic Literary Tone |
| BBC Radio Collection | Multiple | 4.4★ | Documentary | Fitzgerald Deep Dive |
The Great Gatsby narrated by Jake Gyllenhaal
Released in 2013 to coincide with the then upcoming release of the Baz Luhrmann adaptation of The Great Gatsby, the Fitzgerald estate authorised a new audiobook edition, narrated by Hollywood actor Jake Gyllenhaal.
Gyllenhaal’s performance is described as a “faithful delivery” in the voice of Nick Carraway as he narrates to us the events of that summer in New York in 1922. The unabridged audiobook was also an Audie Award nominee in 2014 in the Classic genre.
The adaptation has an average 4.4 rating on Audible with 6.3k ratings, the most rated of all the Audible versions of this novel at the time of writing this post. In turn Gyllenhaal’s performance is rated 4.6 out of 5 with the story receiving an average rating of 4.3 out of 5.
Reviews of Gyllenhaal’s performance says his performance is excellent, “understated – as his character should be – but with just the right pace and gravitas to show glimpses of the tension between the characters”, indeed some reviews even state he is a “perfect narrator”.
Perfect For: People revisiting the book or those who enjoy listening to big name stars narrating their stories. Also fans of Jake Gyllenhaal.
The Great Gatsby: Bolinda Publishing
This 2012 audiobook by Bolinda Publishing version is narrated by Humphrey Bower. Bolinda Publishing is a well-established audiobook publishing company.
Though I haven’t listened to this edition, I have listened to some of their other audiobooks, such as The Story of Tracy Beaker narrated by Sandi Toksvig who I felt was perfectly cast in the part.
This adaptation on Audible has a rating of 4.4 stars out of 160 reviews at the time of writing, with Humphrey Bower’s narration receiving 4.5 stars out of 5 and the story 4.4 out of 5. Most of the reviews are positive, with Bower’s performance as Nick being described as “more true to the character” and the book has been brought to life as though “Nick Caraway is telling his story especially for us”. However one listener does critique his narration of Daisy, stating his voice gave her a “benign Miss Piggy figure which was impossible to take seriously”.
Perfect For: Those who prefer a tried and tested audiobook provider for their stories.
The Great Gatsby by William Hope
This audiobook was created by Naxos Audiobooks and narrated by William Hope. Published in 2010, the audiobook has 4.3 stars out of 5 based on 89 ratings, with both narrator and story being rated 4.5 out of 5.
Again this version William Hope is praised for his narration, described as “well read” and at times “irresistible”. However, other reviews do state that they found parts of the story “difficult to follow” and they “got fed up with the characters” so whether this maybe due to that readers personal taste in the story, or due to the narration is another matter.
Perfect for: Classic literature fans who prefer understated narration that lets Fitzgerald’s prose take centre stage.
The F. Scott Fitzgerald BBC Radio Collection (Wildcard Pick)
While not strictly a standalone audiobook edition of The Great Gatsby, this BBC Radio collection offers something slightly different for listeners already familiar with the novel and looking to explore more of Fitzgerald’s work.
Alongside a BBC reading of The Great Gatsby narrated by Sam Robards, the collection also includes adaptations of Tender is the Night, Babylon Revisited, Bernice Bobs Her Hair, and several lesser-known Fitzgerald stories, as well as bonus documentary-style programmes exploring Fitzgerald’s life and literary legacy.
With only a small number of Audible reviews (4.4 stars based on 15 reviews) this is clearly a more niche release than the mainstream audiobook editions mentioned above. However, the reviews it does have are overwhelmingly positive, particularly praising the BBC’s production quality and professional casting.
One reviewer described the collection as “essential” for Fitzgerald fans, especially because several of the short stories are difficult to find in professionally produced audio form elsewhere. Indeed the performances are rated 4.7 out of 5 with 4.5 for the story.
Perfect For: Dedicated Fitzgerald readers, BBC radio drama fans, and listeners wanting a broader introduction to Fitzgerald beyond Gatsby alone.
Which edition should I choose?
Choose this if you want a modern, cinematic performance with broad appeal → Audible Studios (Jake Gyllenhaal)
Choose this if you want a traditional narrative experience → Bolinda Publishing
Choose this if you want a classic literary tone that lets the prose speak for itself → Naxos
Choose this if you want to learn more about Fitzgerald and his other work → BBC Radio Collection
